Repository navigation
Verify Battlezone (1983) (Atari) - #844
Open
flaviodnz1 wants to merge 1 commit into
Open
flaviodnz1 wants to merge 1 commit into
flaviodnz1 wants to merge 1 commit into
Conversation
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Verifying Battlezone (1983) (Atari)
Checklist
Have adequate installation instructions been provided to match any config files in the DOSZ?
No separate installation or configuration files are required. This IBM PC booter DOSZ contains only
disk1.img; the existing DOSC boots it usingrun_boot: DISK1.IMG.Have any official patches been applied, if necessary?
No applicable official patch was identified for this 1983 Atarisoft IBM PC release. Later Battlezone patches belong to different games and were not applied.
Is the game data in the root of the ZIP (unless game does not work that way)?
Yes. The single
disk1.imgis at the root of the DOSZ. File name, size and available hashes match the unverified DAT.Is the entry in the right variant file (i.e. Freeware)?
Yes. This is the commercial Atarisoft IBM PC release, so promotion to the primary
PureDOSDAT.xmlis appropriate; it is not a freeware variant.Have digital versions (Steam, GOG) been checked for matching?
The Steam/GOG versions considered do not provide a matching 1983 IBM PC booter disk image. No digital storefront payload was independently hash-matched to this disk.
Can the game benefit from using embedded data or embedded patches in the datfile?
No additional embedded data or patch was identified as beneficial. The complete bootable disk image is preserved as one matching DAT member.
Can DoDAT build the game from the install media?
Yes. DoDAT successfully built
Battlezone (1983) (Atari).doszfromdisk1.imgand reported one of one required files written. The same matching input was also packaged by the verification manager.If the game requires a yml in the DOSZ, has it been added to the yml folder in the repo?
Not applicable. No separate external YML file is required. The existing DOSC already includes the
DOS.YMLboot configuration.Are there .PIF or .ICO or Win32 .EXE files that could be excluded?
No. The DOSZ consists of one bootable disk image; there are no loose
.PIF,.ICOor Windows executable files to exclude.Do the file timestamps match the installation media?
Not independently verifiable from the DAT. The DAT entry does not specify an individual file timestamp for
disk1.img, and the DOSZ container timestamp is not evidence of the original floppy's date.Does the DOSZ run standalone?
Yes. The DOSZ was launched without the DOSC in DOSBox Pure, and the disk image booted; an interactive boot/video selection screen was observed.
For CD games, can the game be set up to run without a CD mounted?
Not applicable. This is a floppy-disk PC booter, not a CD game.
For games which include CD images, is there a smaller installation variant that offers the same features but needs less files?
Not applicable. No CD image or CD-based installation variant is involved.
Can the game benefit from using CHDtoOGG?
Not applicable. This is not a CD-audio release and no CHD audio extraction is involved.
Is the game creating a swap file in the .pure.zip that could be avoided by increasing memory size? Or is it creating other bloated files that could be prevented by adding them in the DOSZ?
No significant bloat was observed. The
.pure.zipgenerated after gameplay contained one small member (47 uncompressed bytes; 165 bytes for the ZIP); no large swap/paging file was present in this inspected archive.Does the DOSC contain problematic data (i.e. copyright issue)?
No problematic copyrighted payload was identified in the existing DOSC. The configuration supplies a
DOS.YMLfor launching the game; the game disk remains in the DOSZ.Does the DOSC have copy protection removed, if possible?
No copy-protection obstruction was encountered during the tested gameplay. The DAT already identifies the disk image as a cracked PC booter; no additional protection-removal patch was added to the DOSC.
Is the game running at the correct speed? Is CPU year specified?
Yes. The existing DOSC specifies
cpu_year: 1982, and the game ran at an appropriate observed speed in DOSBox Pure during testing.Is the DOSC auto-running and skipping past any obstructions? Does it use WAITMODECHANGE if possible?
Yes. The existing DOSC uses
run_boot: DISK1.IMGandrun_input: (WAITMODECHANGE); automatic startup was confirmed without manually navigating the earlier boot menu.Does the game have MT-32 support? If so, is it correctly using MT-32 (old) or CM-32L (new), going by the Vogons Wiki?
Not applicable to this 1983 IBM PC booter release. No MT-32 support or compatible driver was identified.
Does the game have General MIDI support?
Not applicable. No General MIDI support or driver was identified for this 1983 IBM PC release.
Is the game set up to run with the best quality graphics options by default?
The game displays correctly using its original CGA-era graphics. No higher-quality graphics mode specific to this release was established during verification.
For certain old games only - are the graphics/audio improved by specifying video_card: pcjr, tandy, or generic_cga?
No PCjr or Tandy enhancement for this particular IBM PC booter edition was established. CGA is the documented original graphics reference; no
video_cardoverride is proposed.Does the game have a mouse cursor that benefits from enabling input_directmouse?
Not applicable. The tested version uses keyboard/joystick-style controls and does not need a mouse cursor or
input_directmouse.Does a game with separate episodes/executables have the options named and ordered properly in the DOSZ? Do they use the run_utility feature?
Not applicable. The DOSZ contains a single self-booting disk image, with no separate episodes, utilities or executables to order.
Does the game share saves with a sequel, expansion, etc? If so, is it updated to use the .savename feature?
Not applicable. No shared-save relationship with another title was identified; a
.savenameentry is not needed.Comment
Verified Battlezone (1983) (Atari), the Atarisoft IBM PC booter release.
Summary of verification:
Proposed changes:
Source qualification: the DAT identifies this image as a cracked PC booter matching TGOD ID 144. The tests establish a matching, functional disk-image package, not an untouched original commercial floppy.